“I do not believe that just because you’re opposed to abortion, that that makes you pro-life. In fact, I think in many cases, your morality is deeply lacking if all you want is a child born but not a child fed, not a child educated, not a child housed. And why would I think that you don’t? Because you don’t want any tax money to go there. That’s not pro-life. That’s pro-birth. We need a much broader conversation on what the morality of pro-life is.”
Sister Joan Chittister, Benedictine Nun, Author and Speaker
In 1982 I was a 21 year old college dropout. I was pregnant, not married and non-too-thrilled by the sound of my exboyfriend’s voice on the phone as he sighed and said, “well I guess we could get married”. I had failed at college, failed at Christianity and failed at this relationship. It was one of the darkest times in my life, yet I’m thankful I still managed to value myself enough to realize how foolish it would be to marry someone who didn’t love me. “No thanks.” I said. “I’m not sure what I’m going to do but that’s not it.” I could hear the relief in his voice as we agreed to talk later.
I spent the next weeks thinking long and hard about my options. My father offered tearfully to pay for an abortion, but I flatly refused. Not because I had strong political views but because I believed that long before this child was conceived, God knew the mess I would make of my life and had a plan for redemption – for all of us.
Before I formed you in the womb I knew[a] you,
before you were born I set you apart Jeremiah 1:5
Setting emotions aside, I began to look logically and realistically at my remaining choices. I could give this child to a family better able to provide for its physical and emotional needs or I could face the daunting obstacles of raising him/her myself. While I was an emotional wreck at the time, I knew I had some marketable skills. I had a good job history/work ethic and the strong and secure faith of my childhood that was becoming increasingly tangible in spite (or maybe as a result) of my failures. The concept of grace had stopped being a Youth Night discussion and had become a daily lifeline for me. Keeping this child would be insanely difficult but doable.
I had a baby girl that spring. I picked the strongest name I could think of, knowing that little Katharine would need strength and courage to face the world with the less than ideal circumstances of her birth. We lived first with family, then in a brand new government housing complex while I worked part time for that first year and went to school.
Ultimately I got a good clerical job and we moved into a 1 bedroom apartment. My twin bed was in the dining room and Kate had the big bedroom to play and sleep. We shopped on a budget. We were mostly vegetarians out of necessity and we wore thrift store clothing. I bought a used car, paid my own insurance, tithed and had a savings account. My dad helped out when one of us had to go the doctor. We weren’t rich but we had enough and we were happy.
In the meantime, Randy married and had a family. He made his child support payments for Kate faithfully. Eventually and very gradually, he and Kate got to know each other before he passed away just last year.
Kate didn’t meet her biological father until she was 14 but she met her daddy when she was four. Paul loved her as his own and to this day she is closer to him than to me. I’m okay with that – proud of it actually. They fought hard for their relationship and are reaping the rewards.
Married for 8 years, Kate is expecting her first child any day now. Only in the coming years will she fully realize the sacrifices that were made on her behalf. That’s how it works – one more subtle part of Eve’s curse I think. We take our parents for granted until that day when we are called on to make the same sacrifices they’ve made for us all along.
I could have easily found a family to adopt my blue eyed, fiery tempered daughter. There are thousands of young couples longing to give a child – especially a baby – a loving home. I chose to raise Kate myself because, after much soul searching, I knew it was the right decision for both of us.
I think Sister Joan makes a good point. Are we really pro-life or just pro-birth? If we’re committed to life (not just breathing) we’ll stop protesting funding for the social programs that allow our young moms to improve their lives. The sliding scale housing I lived in made it possible for me to be fully present in my daughter’s life that first 2 years while I worked part time and attended classes at night. It wasn’t a hand out – it was the help I needed to get to where I could support us on my own.
At the end of the day, the choice to be made was about quality of life for this child and THAT’S what I believe in. I vote that way and I invest my time and money in charities that benefit – improve the life of – children that are coming into this world in less than ideal circumstances. I fought hard for Kate – not just for her right to breathe, but for a certain quality of life for her.
While I weep at the thought of the hundreds of thousands of young lives lost to abortion every year, I’m much more upset about a simultaneously liberal and conservative society that tells walking wounded women that abortion is their best or only choice. Many liberals say it point blank. While I don’t appreciate the aggressiveness I do appreciate that they don’t pussy foot around – they say what they believe.
Conservatives send the same message when we limit opportunities for food, housing and education. We say, however inadvertently, that abortion really is your best/only choice.
We aren’t going to help you make a life but we don’t want you to take one.
As a result, so many women are left with the spiritual, emotional and sometimes physical consequences of a choice they felt they actually had little choice but to make. The women waiting at the abortion clinic aren’t there to make a political statement – they are there because they feel it is their only way to go forward.
There’s a Young Conservatives facebook post going around right now with a guy holding a sign that says “Abortion has never been about choice. It’s about escaping the consequences of your choices by taking all choices away from another human being.” The link goes on to say that “the real choice happens when one makes the conscious decision to take part in sexual relations, and children are often the consequence of that. Instead of aborting, mothers facing hardships should consider options or reach out to the many charities that are willing to help.”
There are so many things wrong with this post I can’t even begin. For one thing, it completely disregards the man’s role/responsibility as well as the innate nature of human sexuality. While Christians all agree about the value/need to wait for marriage to have sex, the reality is that much of the world isn’t governed by our values and, historically, women are left holding the bag.
As my husband recently said, “you can’t put the genie back in the bottle”. Telling pregnant women what they should have done is ridiculous and irrelevant. When conservatives are looking for answers to social issues we’ve got to come up with something besides blaming loose morals (I cringe to remember that I’ve said similar things myself).
I believe that social programs should be the church’s responsibility. Jesus made it clear that we are to care for widows and orphans, reach out to the hungry, sick and imprisoned. So many pro-life, tea party republicans sit in comfortable pews in their churches on the best side of town, giving money towards their own internal programs/dynasties while protesting the very tax funded social programs they weren’t willing to provide. I love the church but I think we’ve gotten it all wrong.
No doubt that, in an ideal world, people wouldn’t have sex outside of marriage. In that same ideal world the church would provide housing, food and education for all of those in need and government would be free to do just that – protect and lead.
We don’t live in an ideal world – on either side – so we’re stuck working to improve the very real world we do live in.
I’m not a fan of militant views on anything. On almost every subject I find that truth and reason lie somewhere midway between idealism and practicality. There can and should be middle ground. There has to be a way to make changes to our social service programs that will give its beneficiaries a leg up without creating codependency.
If liberals and conservatives really will work together, we can have the best of what both bring to the table and come up with fiscally responsible, workable solutions to these very real issues.
How would we have helped to feed, house and educate the 327,653 children that were aborted last year by Planned Parenthood? Let’s get that plan in place and offer real alternatives to women so that they DO have choices.
Only then can we say we are really Pro-Life. Until then we’re just overly vocal idealists, criticizing someone else’s personal life and unimaginably difficult circumstances. Our protests may well be righteous and well-intentioned but they are intrusive and damaging nonetheless.
As for me, I’ll continue to pray for an end to abortion. I’ll also give to, promote and vote for those who are working to provide real and lasting alternatives that will put an end to the cycles of brokenness and poverty that have brought us to this point.
I hope you’ll join me.